New hardened security appliance with most in-depth... » Check Point is extending its comprehensive Industrial Control Systems (ICS) security solution with t... Axis Communications’ Academy celebrates ten years... » This year Axis Communications’ Academy is celebrating ten years, a training initiative that since it... First NSI Gold Certificates of Approval for Invest... » R-ISC Investigation & Surveillance Company Ltd, Global Options and Esoteric Ltd are the first th... New surveillance system for future Royal Navy airc... » Computer-generated image of flight deck operations on the aircraft carrier HMS Queen Elizabeth. (Pic... New qualification to help learners meet event secu... » The HABC Level 2 Certificate in Event Security Operations (QCF) will give learners the knowledge nee... Moxa Europe establishes Moxa University » Moxa Europe's General Manager-Steve LinThe new Moxa University is a formal education and certificati... PPE sector in Turkey is fast growing market for Ma... » Since 2012, Turkey GDP growth rate fluctuates between 2% and 3% each year. Good news for the nationa... Yemeni Political Transition: Un Secretary Genera... » The United Nations Secretary-General, Ban Ki-moon has launched inclusive consultations aimed at rest... Police move quickly to douse fears over unexploded... » Police officers from Brent have continued to liaise with local residents and businesses as work cont... Cloud demonstrates a silver lining for Financ... » Manchester:  A shift in thinking across the financial services sector, embracing the advantages of p...

CLICK HERE TO

Advertise with Vigilance

Got News?

Got news for Vigilance?

Have you got news/articles for us? We welcome news stories and articles from security experts, intelligence analysts, industry players, security correspondents in the main stream media and our numerous readers across the globe.

READ MORE

Subscribe to Vigilance Weekly

Information Security Header

London: Commenting on Kim Dotcom’s offer of a 10,000 euro bounty on the first person to crack his new Mega file storage and sharing service, Venafi says the bounty is likely to be collected, as the encryption keys are stored along with the users’ files on the system.

According to Calum MacLeod, EMEA Director with the Enterprise Key and Certificate Management (EKCM) experts, this means that anyone gaining access to a user’s ID and password will gain access to their encryption key as well, dramatically increasing the compromise likelihood.

“This bizarre, and quite frankly, less secure approach to encryption seems to be in place solely to protect Mr Dotcom from prosecution, on the basis that he and his staff cannot have any knowledge of the data that is being stored on their cloud computing servers,” he said.

“While this is perhaps understandable given the fact that Mr Dotcom was arrested in New Zealand 12 months ago in connection with copyright infringement surrounding his original MegaUpload file storage and sharing service, the lack of security surrounding the encryption keys leaves the system vulnerable,” he added. The encryption keys are the figurative keys to the kingdom, and the attackers can wreak havoc with unfettered access to data and systems with the keys in hand.

The Venafi EMEA Director went on to say that Mr Dotcom’s offer of a bounty to successful crackers of his new system is good publicity, but a more practical governance approach would have been to stage a private launch of Mega, inviting cryptographers to use - and abuse - the system, and then offer up their recommendations in return for a lifetime paid-for subscription.

The problem with Mega, MacLeod explained, is that the user’s password has the double burden of supporting account authentication - without disclosing that password to Mega’s servers – as well as outer level data encryption.

The outer level key, he says, is derived from the user’s password using a key derivation approach, generating a master key for symmetric AES encryption – all data from that point on is encrypted to the master key or its subsets.

When the user logs into the Mega service, he adds, their email address and user hash data is used to authenticate them, with Mega’s servers returning the user’s master key, as well as a session identifier.

This approach, says MacLeod, is a weak security system as obtaining the master key is based on a simple token system that can be replayed, rather than the more usual secure challenge/response technology seen on commercial services.

“This weakness could be exploited through the use of a timing vulnerability when the server compares the user’s hash data, allowing a hacker to progressively learn how to access the system using multiple attempts. We fully expect this methodology to be exploited by would-be crackers wanting to collect the 10,000 euro bounty,” he said.

In the end, it’s critical that the encryption keys that secure the data and authenticate systems and applications are properly controlled and managed. The admins who create and issue the keys should not be the same as the admins and app owners who use the same keys to encrypt, decrypt and access the data